Friday, February 7, 2025
18.6 C
Canberra

AI chatbot DeepSeek celebrated in China despite concerns elsewhere

DeepSeek's Chinese creators claim its performance is on par with the latest Western AI chatbots. (Reuters: Dado Ruvic)

When Ye Shengwei first asked the new Chinese artificial intelligence (AI) chatbot DeepSeek to write an article for him, he was amazed by its quality.

"It provided in-depth analysis and told me the reasons why it was generating that content," Mr Ye said.

"It gave me some surprisingly good points for the topic and drew some useful conclusions."

AI chatbot DeepSeek celebrated in China despite concerns elsewhere

Ye Shengwei has been impressed by DeepSeek's capability.  (Supplied)

Mr Ye, 35, works for a major tech company as a software product manager and so had already been using Western AI chatbots to draft articles for work.

The Chinese government's "Great Firewall" blocks access to Western websites for ordinary citizens.

Mr Ye said he thought ChatGPT was the best AI tool but after using the home-grown Chinese chatbot, he said he might change his preference.

"ChatGPT's output still requires me to manually edit and polish sentence by sentence, which still is time-consuming, and it tends to give me vague conclusions," Mr Ye said.

"If DeepSeek can make my writing more efficient, I'll keep using it."

'The best Lunar New Year gift'

Since the release of its new AI model R1 on January 20, DeepSeek has been dominating global headlines, shaking the stock market, wowing computer scientists and stoking pride in China.

Creator High-Flyer Quant — a previously little-known AI hedge fund company — claims it was built in the face off US restrictions on the latest technology for a tiny fraction of the cost of AI models such as ChatGPT, and that it is much more efficient.

What is DeepSeek? Why the AI startup is up-ending the US stock market

Photo shows A phone with DeepSeek on it. Behind it is a screen with ChatGPT

AI chatbot DeepSeek celebrated in China despite concerns elsewhere

DeepSeek's AI assistant — a direct competitor to ChatGPT — has become the number one downloaded free app on Apple's App Store, with some worrying the Chinese startup has disrupted the US market. 

Its release coincided with the return to the White House of Donald Trump, who called it a "wake-up call" for American companies.

Chinese netizens shared their excitement on social media, with one describing it as "the best Lunar New Year gift".

"I think DeepSeek is fully capable of doing the job, and it's much clearer in logic, which is very suitable for Chinese students," one Chinese social media user posted.

"I've already unsubscribed from ChatGPT and plan to stick with DeepSeek."

AI chatbot DeepSeek celebrated in China despite concerns elsewhere

Users have found that DeepSeek censors queries related to subjects uncomfortable for Beijing including the Tiananmen crackdown. (Reuters)

Censorship and data security concerns

While the Chinese government, state media, and users have lavishly praised DeepSeek, others have expressed concerns about censorship and potential surveillance by Beijing.

In-built restrictions limit DeepSeek's responses to questions about subjects that are sensitive in China, such as the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989.

Some, including Australian cabinet ministers, have also warned that people should be careful when using DeepSeek and be aware of their data security.

"It's fine to talk to the app but perhaps don't give it personal information that you don't want the rest of the world to know," Housing Minister Clare O'Neil told Seven's Sunrise program.

Science Minister Ed Husic told ABC News there remained a lot of unanswered questions, including over "data and privacy management".

"I would be very careful about that. These types of issues need to be weighed up carefully," he added.

Nicholas Davis, an AI expert at the University of Technology Sydney, said a lot of platforms censored content, and in China "the government regulates what material is shown".

"All AI models have been fine-tuned to shape the outputs in certain directions," he said.

AI chatbot DeepSeek celebrated in China despite concerns elsewhere

Nicholas Davis is an AI expert at the University of Technology Sydney. (Supplied)

According to Professor Davis, scientists have successfully removed the censorship in some open-sourced Chinese models and, theoretically, it could be done with DeepSeek as well.

"An important question is, in the case of DeepSeek, are people worried about specific topics of censorship? Or do people care that it is a Chinese company?"

Professor Davis said data security was a bigger concern than censorship and one that was relevant to all the AI platforms.

"Personally, a bigger issue is the risks created by typing personal information [into an online large language model (LLM)]," he said.

"For example, I would never put any sensitive work information into [an internet] browser-based large language model, because I know that companies like Anthropic and OpenAI can see and potentially use what I'm writing.

A 'wake-up call' from China threatens America's AI vision

Photo shows A while logo next to the word 'DeepSeek' on a phone screen sitting on top of a keyboard.

AI chatbot DeepSeek celebrated in China despite concerns elsewhere

The US was seen to have a major lead in the field of AI, and export bans in place were meant to keep it that way. China's new AI tool challenges those assumptions.

"I feel just as concerned when it comes to DeepSeek. If I worked in the government, I may feel even more concerned about using DeepSeek.

"That's not a question about censorship. That's a question about, 'What happened to my data?' and 'How could that data be used?'

"However, if everyone is using DeepSeek and only DeepSeek, yes, censorship is a critical social problem because free speech supports democracy.

"But I would argue that privacy is the bigger issue right now.

"People might easily think, 'I'm going to use this AI to organise my finances.'

"With any LLM, this would expose sensitive information that could come back to bite you."

A breakthrough 'we should be engaging with deeply'

Professor Davis said he had been testing and benchmarking DeepSeek, which can be installed on users' computers to be used locally instead of via the internet.

He said it was "extremely good" and he was impressed by its efficiency.

Who is Liang Wenfeng, the founder of AI company DeepSeek?

Photo shows Two men sitting on a table speaking.

AI chatbot DeepSeek celebrated in China despite concerns elsewhere

Liang Wenfeng is now leading China in its AI revolution as the superpower attempts to keep pace with the dominant AI industry in the United States. But who is the founder of DeepSeek?

"If I'm on a long plane trip, now I can run an extremely capable model directly on my MacBook during the flight," he said.

"I don't need an internet connection and ask a server to run ChatGPT or [Anthropic's AI chatbot] Claude for me. I can just do it locally.

He said that despite people's concerns, open-source models such as DeepSeek could assist with broader understanding of the technology.

"If it's all controlled and managed entirely and only within large tech companies, that means there is less opportunity for independent experts and the community to play, to test and to understand it," he said.

"DeepSeek is a really interesting genuine breakthrough that we should be engaging with deeply."

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Hot this week

Topics

spot_img